Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

Is a metal or traditional roof right for your Wisconsin home?

Snow, hail, ice dams, noise, and investment compared by a local GAF Master Elite roofing company.

Quick answer: For most Chippewa Valley homes, a well-installed architectural shingle like GAF Timberline HDZ is the best value, and a standing seam or stone-coated steel roof is a premium choice that typically costs about double. Choose metal if you want a distinctive look and plan to stay for decades; choose shingles if budget, a complex roofline, or easy repairs matter most. Either way, the attic determines whether ice dams return.

Drive around Eau Claire, Chippewa Falls, or the lakes near Bloomer and Fall Creek, and you'll see more metal roofs every year. Some homeowners love them. Others worry about noise, dents, or snow crashing off the eaves. Rock & Tait is a GAF Master Elite contractor, and we install both every season, so here's what we tell our own neighbors.

The Three Kinds of Metal Roofs (and which one belongs on a house)

  • Standing seam steel. Long, clean vertical panels with the fasteners hidden underneath. This is the steel roof we recommend for homes. We install Pro-Snap, made right here in Eau Claire by Midwest Manufacturing and Hixwood.
  • Stone-coated steel. Steel panels coated in stone granules and shaped like shake, shingle, or tile. We install Unified Steel, backed by a 50-year transferable limited manufacturer warranty that includes Class 4 hail.
  • Ribbed, exposed-fastener steel. The familiar look on pole sheds and farm buildings (Pro-Rib by Midwest Manufacturing or Super-Rib 100 by Hixwood). It costs about the same as a designer shingle, but it isn't our pick for a house. Many homeowners don't love the pole-shed look, and the rubber gaskets around the exposed screws wear out over time. For garages, shops, and outbuildings, it's a great choice, and we can match it to your home.

How Metal and Shingles Compare in a Wisconsin Winter

  • Snow. Steel sheds snow fast, sometimes all at once. That's great for the roof and dangerous over a front door, deck, walkway, or driveway. On any steel roof, we highly recommend snow guards above doors, walkways, driveways, and decks. In fact, we suggest them all the way around for safety. Shingles hold snow longer.
  • Ice dams. Metal does not fix ice dams. If warm, moist air is leaking into your attic, you'll still get ice at the eaves, and it can be harder to manage on a slick roof. Fix the attic first, whatever roof material you choose.
  • Hail. Steel resists punctures, but big hail can leave permanent cosmetic dents in smooth panels. Stone-coated steel hides dents better. If hail is your main worry, a Class 4 shingle such as GAF Timberline UHDZ with UltraMat may get you most of the protection for far less money. On many of our projects, UHDZ runs about 10% more than HDZ.
  • Noise. Over a solid roof deck with underlayment and an insulated attic, most people barely notice rain on steel. The loud metal roofs you remember are usually on open-framed barns.
  • Repairs. After a storm, replacing a few shingles is simple. A damaged steel panel can be harder to match years later if the color has changed.

How the Cost Compares

We don't post prices on the website because your roof's size, pitch, and details determine the real number. But here's the ladder from our own projects. GAF Timberline HDZ is our most common roof and the lowest-cost way into a lifetime shingle. UHDZ is about 10% more. GAF's value designer shingles are about 50% more. Standing seam, stone-coated steel, and synthetic slate or shake sit in the premium tier at typically about double an HDZ roof. Percentages are averages from our projects, not quotes.

Where Each Makes the Most Sense

Metal shines on:

  • Lake homes and cabins where you want snow to clear and a look that stands out
  • Simple roof shapes with long, uninterrupted runs
  • Porch, bay window, and entry accent roofs paired with a shingle main roof
  • Homeowners staying for the long haul who want something better and different, so their home doesn'tlook like everyone else's

Shingles win on:

  • Complex roofs with lots of valleys, dormers, and walls, which are easier to detail with shingles
  • Tighter budgets, or a home you may sell in a few years
  • Insurance claims where you don't want to pay a large upgrade difference

A Call We Get Every Spring

A family near Lake Wissota had a 1990s shingle roof, an ice dam over the kitchen every February, and a long list of "maybe we should go metal" questions. When we got into the attic, the ice dam had nothing to do with shingles. The bath fans dumped into the attic, and the top plates were wide open. We sealed and insulated the attic, vented the fans outside, and installed standing seam with snow guards over the deck stairs and garage. The next winter the eaves stayed clear, and the kids could use the deck stairs without anyone watching the roof. This story is similar to one we hear every year. 

The Parts You Never See Matter More than the Materials

Under every steel roof we install, we install a leak barrier to code plus a synthetic underlayment, with a high-temperature underlayment where the manufacturer calls for it. Under every shingle roof, leak barrier runs 6 feet up the eaves, 3 feet into every valley, at least 5 inches up every sidewall, and in a 20-inch square around every penetration. Either way, we look at the attic while the roof is open, because the roof is the one time we can fix ventilation and insulation from above. Waiting on a worn-out roof rarely makes the decision easier. A slow leak soaks insulation and rots decking, and a straightforward roof replacement can lead to repairs inside the house, too. Learn how we inspect attics when we replace roofs.

Compare metal and shingles side by side

Call Rock & Tait at 715-723-7200 or request a free estimate. We serve Eau Claire and every city within 30miles, including Chippewa Falls, Altoona, Menomonie, Lake Hallie, Bloomer, Elk Mound, Colfax, Fall Creek, Osseo, and Augusta. We'll look at your roof and attic, bring real samples to your kitchen table, and put good, better, and best options in writing, with no pressure. Or stop by our Eau Claire showroom to see steel and shingles side by side.

Increase your comfort.
Decrease your energy bill.

Find out how your home ranks.